'Diwali Cleaning' Is No Excuse: Delhi High Court Refuses Late Evidence in BROWN SUGAR Trademark Suit
By Imaduddin Photo: anncapictures / Pixabay In trademark disputes, evidence of early use often decides who wins. A decision of the Delhi High Court in M/s Cafe Brown Sugar Pvt Ltd v. Vyom Foodcraft Pvt Ltd (2026:DHC:9604), reported on 30 October 2026, shows how strictly that evidence must be filed on time in Indian commercial suits. The case The plaintiff sued in November 2024 for trademark and copyright infringement and passing off over its "BROWN SUGAR" family of marks. It claims use since 2000. The defendants claim use from 2010. Prior use is therefore at the centre of the case. The plaintiff asked to add sales invoices, purchase bills, promotional material and tax deduction certificates dated between 2003 and 2011. It said the documents had been found in old cartons during a Diwali cleaning in 2025, and explained that its business had changed management after the death of a former director. The rule Order XI Rule 1(5) of the Code of Civil Procedure, as it applie…